On Social Media, Learn When to Keep Your Mouth Shut
This is a guest post by Shanna Mallon, a writer for Straight North, an Internet marketing Chicago company that provides SEO, Web development and other online marketing services to B2B clients.
The other day, I was sitting at a quiet window-front table in the coffee shop, sipping a latte and working on my laptop, when the thing every writer dreads happened: just behind me, at a large corner table, one loud and assertive voice started dominating the entire room. And with every off-color joke and obnoxious laugh he made everyone nearby listen to, I grew more sure of one thing: I wished he would just shut up already.
This sort of thing doesn’t only happen in the world of coffee shops and restaurants. According to the 2010 Cone Consumer New Media Study, over half of social media users will stop following you if you talk too much and/or if the information you provide isn’t relevant to them.
When you come across as an online loudmouth, you lose your credibility and scope of influence.
That’s why, sometimes, the most important thing you can do for your online reputation is one of the most overlooked: stop talking.
There are all kinds of ways people lose followers by overcommunicating on social media, and they’re about much more than too many Tweets. Here are some examples—could any of these describe your brand?
Not Speaking Your Audience’s Language
You know how it is when you’re talking to someone and he doesn’t pick up on any normal social cues? You said you weren’t really interested in politics, but he keeps quoting pundits. You crossed your arms when he asked about your family, but he keeps probing. Well, that’s exactly what it’s like when you post, Tweet or blog in a way that doesn’t consider and connect with your followers.
Understanding your audience is key to being able to reach them. What does they care about? What are their desires, fears, hopes? What are they saying?
Once you know these things, find a way to translate that knowledge into helpful, friendly dialogue that is a real conversation between you and them, in the style and tone they’re used to. Otherwise, you’d be better off not saying anything.
Doing All the Talking
It’s as true on social media as it is in real life: to build relationships, you must learn to listen. In the online world, your responses matter just as much (sometimes more!) as what you say because when followers get the sense that you only want a monologue, that’s one of the fastest roads to unfollows.
Listening well online means saying less, as well as making it a practice to skim your feeds on Twitter, Facebook and blogs and, when something interests you or your industry, respond in a thoughtful, authentic way.
Beating the Same Drum—Over and Over Again
Too many brands turn their feeds into boring, repetitive posts always about their company. While in theory, any social media presence is good, here’s the thing with posting the same kind of self-promoting content day in and day out—at some point, any reader is going to look at it and ask that crucial online question: what’s in it for me?
Always talk-talk-talking about your company makes you as guilty as that man in my coffee shop, and pretty soon, no one will care what you have to say. Better to vary your content and post about yourself less, opting for quality over quantity in promoting your brand.
What do you think? Are these descriptions true to your own experience in social media, either as a follower or as the one followed? Do they matter? What other ways have you seen people talk too much online?
8 Responses to On Social Media, Learn When to Keep Your Mouth Shut
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
Kelly Kautz is one woman on a mission to prove that marketing your business doesn't have to suck.
- Brain Sex: Five Things You Must Know About Gender and Marketing
- How to Create a Blog Schedule, with Free Templates
- Seven Ways Your Website Makes Baby Jesus Cry
- Copywriting From the Heart: Free Workbook
- The Small Business Blogging Blueprint: Free 55-page eBook
- How to Make a Social Media Marketing Plan








When being on any social network site, you need to learn when to keep your mouth shut. In this case, don’t let your fingers override your brain when typing out anything that comes to mind.
Before saying something online about your school district, job, items on the menu, posting pics, and a slew of other things, would you say that to a person’s face? If not, keep your fingers to yourself and don’t post online anything that could land you in hot water.
John Cooper recently posted…Blog about Crohn\’s
I totally agree with this post Kelly but sometimes, If you just keep your mouth shut, people would think that you are just playing safe just to get followers and keep them following you, Talking to them is also a good idea in a way but like you said, over talking isn’t that good for a great blogger…
Thank you for sharing this post…..
Keep it up..
I have the opposite problem, I can’t think of what to say! Trying to learn though
You are perfectly right from my point of view. Everyone needs to feel like being important, therefore doing all the conversation by ourselves and crowding everyone else with our problems and thought, won’t build a relationship stronger. On the contrary, we might get the opposite reaction and destroy our online brand. Social networks are great, but we have to behave properly.
Jack Sander recently posted…Garden arbor plans
John, You make a good point that sometimes holding our tongue is more about not saying something stupid than it is about overtalking. We’ve all put our feet in our mouths at one point or another in the offline world—and in the online one, doing so can have even more permanent consequences.
Peejay, Definitely we need to engage with people on social media—I think that’s what you’re pointing out with your comment—but how we engage with them is worth thinking through.
Home, One of the best pieces advice I’ve heard about social media is sharing what’s got your attention. If you find something interesting, your connections might, too.
Jack, It’s true. To build connections, we have to connect. And you can’t do that on your own, having a monologue. Good point!
Shanna Mallon recently posted…Why Corporate Website Content Is So Dull
This post speaks volumes. I absolutely HATE when people sit on sites like Facebook and continuously update their status. For crying out loud…how many times can one post status updates in a day? Well this is what I asked myself when I saw some people posting so many times in one day. If the posts were interesting I wouldn’t mind. I post on Facebook on a daily basis, but have not been there for a while. Got to get back in the swing of things. Thanks for sharing this post. I totally agree and really enjoyed reading it.
Social Media are the place where you can express, advertise and say something else but it is very important to know when you are going to shut your mouth when it seems over. Thanks a lot for sharing this tips and I learn a lot of things!
Zia Courtney recently posted…How You Can Afford Brisbanes Prestige Commercial Joinery
Pingback: Straight North around the Web, 4 | Straight North Internet Marketing Blog